Thinking about a restructure, relocation or redundancies and worried it could end up at tribunal? You can never remove risk completely, but you can reduce it sharply with a fair, transparent and lawful process. In the UK, that means following the Employment Rights Act 1996, the Trade Union and Labour Relations (Consolidation) Act 1992, and the Equality Act 2010.

In this guide, you’ll learn how to build a solid business case, consult well, choose fair criteria, manage relocations and suitable alternatives, and close out the process with care. We link to official guidance and laws so you can act with confidence, and we keep people at the centre.

Why do restructures, relocations and redundancies lead to tribunal claims?

A restructure, relocation or redundancy can involve dismissal or contractual change, which triggers strict legal duties. Claims often arise when consultation is rushed, criteria are biased, or alternatives are not explored.

Under the Employment Rights Act 1996 your decisions must be fair and reasonable, and you must follow a fair process before dismissing. Unfair dismissal and discrimination are common risks, alongside breach of contract when changing terms. The Equality Act 2010 bans discrimination on protected grounds, including disability, sex and age. A flawed process can also lead to a protective award for collective redundancies. Using a values-led, evidence-based process reduces these risks and protects your culture.

What makes a robust, ethical business case for change?

A strong case explains why the change is needed now, what options you tested, and how you minimise harm. Clear evidence helps employees and any tribunal see that you acted reasonably.

Build your case with:

  • Strategic rationale, such as funding changes, duplication of roles, or location viability, written in plain language employees can understand.
  • Financial and operational evidence that supports the need for change, for example cost pressures or efficiency concerns, not just preferences.
  • Alternatives considered, for example vacancy controls, redeployment, retraining, or natural attrition, with reasons for rejection.
  • People impact assessment, including equality considerations and mitigation steps for groups who might be disproportionately affected under the Equality Act 2010.
  • Ethical commitments, such as enhanced consultation, wellbeing support and fair redeployment rules, consistent with your values.

We have seen organisations gain trust quickly when they share summaries of their evidence and commit to listening before decisions are final.

How do you run a fair redundancy or restructure process step by step?

Follow a staged plan, consult early, and document every decision. This creates fairness for people and a clear audit trail for any challenge.

Timeline you can adapt:

1) Define scope and roles at risk

Draft proposed structure charts, role profiles and selection pools. Explain which roles are changing or ceasing and why under the Employment Rights Act 1996.

2) Choose objective selection criteria

Use measurable criteria linked to business needs, such as skills, qualifications, performance evidence and disciplinary record. Avoid any criteria that could indirectly discriminate under the Equality Act 2010.

3) Prepare the consultation pack

Include your business case, proposed timeline, selection approach, and a clear invitation to suggest alternatives. Follow ACAS redundancy guidance on meaningful consultation.

4) Start consultation before decisions

Hold group and one-to-one meetings. Listen to alternatives such as redeployment, reduced hours, or job redesign. Keep minutes and provide follow-up notes.

5) Apply criteria fairly and check bias

Calibrate scoring across managers, keep evidence for each score, and allow employees to challenge their scores.

6) Explore suitable alternative roles and adjustments

Offer trial periods and reasonable adjustments where appropriate. The Equality Act 2010 requires you to consider adjustments for disabled employees.

7) Confirm outcomes and rights

Issue clear outcome letters, reasons, and information on notice, redundancy pay and appeal. Use the GOV.UK redundancy pay calculator to estimate statutory entitlements.

8) Close well and support leavers

Offer references, outplacement and wellbeing support. A compassionate close reduces future disputes and protects your brand.

What are the UK rules on collective redundancy consultation?

If you propose 20 or more redundancies at one establishment within 90 days, you must consult collectively and meet minimum timeframes. You also need to notify the government using form HR1.

When proposing 20 to 99 redundancies, consultation must start at least 30 days before the first dismissal, and 45 days for 100 or more, under the Trade Union and Labour Relations (Consolidation) Act 1992. Failure to collectively consult can result in a protective award of up to 90 days’ pay per affected employee under the Trade Union and Labour Relations (Consolidation) Act 1992. You must also notify the Secretary of State on form HR1, and failure to notify is a criminal offence, as explained on GOV.UK collective consultation.

Collective consultation does not replace individual consultation. You still need one-to-ones to explore personal circumstances and alternatives.

How should you select fairly and avoid discrimination claims?

Use objective, evidence-based criteria and apply them consistently. Avoid anything that could directly or indirectly discriminate under the Equality Act 2010.

Selection good practice:

  • Link criteria to role requirements, not popularity or flexibility, and define what strong, acceptable and weak evidence looks like.
  • Use recent, documented performance data rather than memory or hearsay. Calibrate across managers to reduce bias.
  • Avoid attendance-based criteria that penalise disability or pregnancy-related absence. Record lawful exclusions where required by the Equality Act 2010.
  • Keep contemporaneous notes that explain every score and decision. If challenged, your paper trail will matter.
  • Allow employees to view their scores and raise concerns during consultation.

What if you are relocating, using mobility clauses, or offering alternatives?

Relocation needs a fair process, even if you have a mobility clause. You should consult, assess reasonableness, and consider suitable alternatives.

  • Mobility clauses are not a free pass. Tribunals assess reasonableness based on distance, personal impact, notice and support. Engage with the individual’s circumstances.
  • Suitable alternative employment must be genuinely comparable in terms, status, pay and location. Employees have a statutory four-week trial period to assess suitability, as explained on GOV.UK job offers in redundancy.
  • If no suitable alternative exists, or refusal is reasonable, the employee may qualify for statutory redundancy pay under the Employment Rights Act 1996, which you can estimate using the GOV.UK redundancy calculator.
  • Consider flexible or hybrid arrangements. The day-one right to request flexible working took effect in April 2024 and ACAS has updated guidance on flexible working.

How do you consult well without causing unnecessary harm?

Meaningful consultation is two-way, early and humane. Invite ideas, respond to them, and be transparent.

  • Start before decisions are final. Share your business case and listen with curiosity.
  • Provide clear letters, FAQs and timelines. Use plain English and avoid jargon.
  • Allow accompaniment at meetings as a supportive measure, even though it is not a strict legal requirement in redundancy consultation.
  • Keep minutes and confirm actions in writing. Employees appreciate accuracy and clarity.
  • Offer wellbeing resources and signpost support. Values-led employers balance legal process with human care.

One charity we supported created a staff suggestion route that led to a redeployment plan. Several roles were saved and trust increased across the team.

What documents and data practices reduce dispute risk?

Good paperwork and data hygiene protect both people and the organisation. They also make any challenge easier to defend.

Documents to prepare and maintain:

  • Business case summary, proposed structure, and impact assessment
  • Consultation letters, meeting invites, and minutes
  • Selection matrices with evidence and calibration notes
  • Outcome letters, notice details, and appeal routes
  • Redundancy pay calculations and settlement documentation where used

Handle personal data under the UK General Data Protection Regulation. The Information Commissioner’s Office provides guidance on lawful basis, data minimisation and retention. Keep only what you need, for no longer than necessary, and secure it appropriately.

What payments, notice and rights do you need to manage correctly?

Employees may be entitled to statutory redundancy pay, notice pay, accrued holiday pay and other sums. Get these right and you reduce disputes.

  • Statutory redundancy pay depends on age, length of service and weekly pay, and you can estimate it using the GOV.UK calculator.
  • Statutory minimum notice is at least one week for each complete year of service, up to a maximum of 12 weeks, as set out on GOV.UK notice periods.
  • Pay in lieu of notice and settlement agreements need careful drafting and tax handling. Seek advice before you commit.

What common mistakes lead to employment tribunal claims?

You can avoid many pitfalls with planning and good notes. Here is a quick checklist.

Checklist:

  • Rushing consultation or presenting decisions as final from day one
  • Using subjective or discriminatory selection criteria without evidence
  • Ignoring reasonable adjustments for disabled employees
  • Skipping collective consultation where thresholds are met
  • Forgetting to submit the HR1 form in collective redundancies
  • Mishandling notice, redundancy pay or holiday pay calculations
  • Poor record-keeping and unclear communication throughout

When should you bring in expert HR support?

Bring in help early if you lack capacity, face collective thresholds, or need complex redeployment and TUPE advice. An external partner protects your organisation and your people.

Specialised HR supports ethical, values-led employers to navigate change lawfully and compassionately. Explore our dedicated page on Redundancy, Restructuring & TUPE, see the breadth of our HR Services, or Book a Free Consultation if you want a second pair of eyes on your plan.

Ready to run a fair, values-led change process with confidence? Start with a friendly chat: Book a Free Consultation, review our Redundancy, Restructuring & TUPE support, or request a Free HR Docs Review.

FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS

What is the difference between restructure, relocation and redundancy?

A restructure changes roles or reporting lines, a relocation changes where work happens, and redundancy removes roles. In practice, they often overlap.

For example:

  • A restructure can make some roles redundant if the work no longer exists
  • A relocation may trigger redundancy if there’s no suitable alternative or a move is unreasonable
  • All three require consultation and a fair, evidence-based process

Treat each scenario with care, explain your rationale, and keep open to alternatives like redeployment or job redesign.

Why do employment tribunal claims happen after redundancies?

Claims usually follow poor process, unclear reasons, or discrimination. We often see issues where consultation is too short, scores lack evidence, or alternatives are ignored.

Risks include:

  • Unfair dismissal under the Employment Rights Act 1996
  • Discrimination under the Equality Act 2010
  • Protective awards for failing to collectively consult

A transparent process with clear notes and timely letters reduces the likelihood of a claim and supports better outcomes for people.

What UK laws apply to redundancies and restructures?

The Employment Rights Act 1996, the Equality Act 2010, and the Trade Union and Labour Relations (Consolidation) Act 1992 apply. In practice, you should also follow ACAS guidance.

Key points include:

  • Fair reason and fair procedure for any dismissal
  • Non-discrimination in criteria and decisions
  • Collective consultation thresholds when 20 or more redundancies are proposed
  • Proper record-keeping and clear communication

TUPE may apply if you are transferring services or merging entities.

What is a protective award in collective redundancies?

A protective award is compensation when an employer fails to properly consult collectively on proposed redundancies. If you plan 20 or more redundancies, you must collectively consult and meet minimum timescales. If you do not, an employment tribunal can award pay for a set period. Employers should also file form HR1 to notify the government. Taking advice early, planning timelines, and meeting with elected representatives are the best ways to avoid this risk.

How do I choose fair selection criteria for redundancy?

Pick objective, measurable and role-related criteria, then apply them consistently with evidence. Good criteria often include skills, qualifications, documented performance, and relevant experience. Avoid criteria that could discriminate, such as flexibility if it penalises carers, or attendance that includes disability or pregnancy-related absences. Calibrate scores across managers, let employees review their scores, and keep a clear audit trail of how you decided each one.

How should I consult employees during a restructure?

Consult early, share your business case, and genuinely invite alternatives.

Helpful steps include:

  • Group and one-to-one meetings with time for questions
  • Clear letters, FAQs and proposed timelines
  • Space for employees to challenge selection scores
  • Consideration of redeployment, reduced hours, or job redesign Keep minutes and provide follow-up notes.

Many employers allow accompaniment in consultation meetings to support employee wellbeing and reduce anxiety.

How do I handle a relocation fairly if I have a mobility clause?

A mobility clause still requires reasonableness and consultation. Explain the business need, consider personal impact, and offer support. Look at distance, travel time, caring duties and health. Explore alternatives like hybrid work or phased moves. Offer suitable alternative roles where possible, with a four-week statutory trial period. If a move is unreasonable, or no suitable role exists, redundancy may be appropriate with the correct payments and notice.

What documents do I need to defend my process if challenged?

You need a complete, consistent paper trail from start to finish.

Prepare and keep:

  • Business case and proposed structures
  • Consultation invites, minutes and responses
  • Selection criteria, scoring matrices and calibration notes
  • Outcome letters, notice details and appeal records
  • Redundancy pay calculations and settlement agreements

Store personal data securely and only as long as necessary in line with UK GDPR. Good notes make disputes shorter and less stressful.

How do statutory notice and redundancy pay work in the UK?

Statutory redundancy pay depends on age, weekly pay and length of service, and statutory notice runs from one to a maximum of twelve weeks.

To stay accurate:

  • Use the official GOV.UK redundancy calculator to estimate pay
  • Check contractual notice, which may be more generous than statutory
  • Remember holiday accrues during notice
  • Get advice before offering pay in lieu of notice or settlements

Handling pay and notice correctly reduces the chance of later disputes.

When should I get external HR help during a restructure?

Bring in support as soon as you see complexity or capacity gaps. External experts add value when you face collective thresholds, sensitive equality issues, multiple locations, or TUPE. They can help with timelines, scripts, selection matrices, union engagement, and HR1 notifications. Many clients also ask for an objective review of their scoring and letters. Early input prevents rework, builds trust, and keeps your plan on the right side of the law.

Related Resources

 

See how Specialised HR supports ethical employers through lawful, people-first change projects, including consultation and documentation.

Talk through your plan, get a risk check on timelines and letters, and map next steps with an experienced consultant.

Explore ongoing and project-based HR support, from employee relations to change programmes, tailored to values-led organisations.

 

Further Reading

    Clear, employer-friendly guidance on fair process, consultation and selection, with templates and checklists.

    Guidance on lawful processing, retention and security when handling employee data during change programmes.

    Need some help with your organisation?

    For reassurance when you’re dealing with a similar situation you can contact us for expert advice on the best way to proceed.

    Ethical HR consultancy services

    Specialised HR is an award-winning HR consultancy that has been recognised for excellence in the field.

    Our services cater to small to medium businesses, not-for-profits and charities throughout the UK.

    We offer comprehensive HR support to help organisations effectively address their employee issues.

    Our approach is centred around the individual needs of our clients – each organisation is assigned a dedicated HR Consultant.

    Certificate Showing of Specialised HR's 100% Success Rate with no clients going to employment tribunals

    Our range of employment and human resources services include

    • Creating HR documents such as policies and procedures, contracts of employment and offer letters
    • Providing access to an employment law helpline
    • Employee engagement initiatives
    • Employers’ liability insurance
    • Assisting with payroll and pensions
    • Supporting and leading restructures, redundancies and organisational change
    • Managing recruitment processes
    • Overseeing performance management and appraisal procedures
    • Supporting home/remote working
    • Resolving employee disputes
    • Offering safeguarding workplace investigation services
    • Management 121 coaching

    How Clients Work With Us

    Support can be provided on an ad-hoc, pay-as-you-go basis to address real-time needs or through monthly retainers, offering cost-effective solutions. We are transparent with our prices and packages.

    Ready to build a calm, consistent, people-first culture that lasts?

    Book a Call | HR Services | Training Courses | HR Resources

    Business Case Study

    How we helped a medium sized business reduce staff turnover and build improved staff retention

    What Our Clients Say

    Subscribe to Blog via Email

    Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

    Discover more from Specialised HR

    Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

    Continue reading